'Gross' Tap Water Galvanizes Malvernites, LI American Water President Offers Insight

Over one hundred residents have joined a Facebook group against the brown water being supplied by Long Island American Water. The company's president sheds some light on the problem.

Dawn Wladyka, a mother of three, dreads bath time in her Malverne home. Turning on the faucet sometimes turns on the "water works"' in her kids, as they protest plunging into the brown, putrid-looking fluid that often fills her tub.

"It is pretty much always like this," she says of the murky tap water that has become common in her home.

Not only is the color offensive, but it has left behind a rust-colored residue on the bottom of the tub, and has raised concerns about whether the water is safe for her family, including her two dogs, to ingest.

(CHECK OUT the PHOTOS AND VIDEO to see for yourself.)

For the past five years, she and her husband have called in servicemen to look at the problem, experimented with filters and draining tanks and even considered replacing their hot water heater – but they were told there is nothing wrong with the one currently in their home.

Wladyka, who once enjoyed taking baths before moving to her home in Malverne, now opts for a quick shower because she can not bring herself to soak in the brown water. Even her young kids have started to protest.

"My kids are now old enough to be disgusted by the color of the water that they bathe in," Wladyka said. She told Patch her breaking point was when her youngest daughter was brought to tears because she didn't want to wash in the dirty-looking bath water. Her mother doesn’t blame her, adding, “It’s gross!”

This weekend, Wladyka learned that she is not alone.

In the past 48 hours, over 100 residents of Malverne and neighboring Lynbrook have joined a Facebook group named "I love Malverne but hate the brown water (From LI Water)."

The group, started by Malverne resident and former Civic President Tom Grech, asks residents to share their stories about dealing with the repulsive water running through their homes and plans to circulate a petition that would be presented to Long Island American Water, the supplier.

Grech, also a parent and 10-year village resident, has observed brown water and particles coming out of the faucets in his basement, kitchen and bathroom, for years and has noticed that it has only gotten worse.

“We get very fine sediment that comes out in the bathtub and sink when we run the hot water," he said in an interview this week.

He’s even witnessed the cold water coming out of his sink turn the revolting brown color too, although like most of the members of the Facebook group and residents interviewed by Patch, the problem occurs more frequently when running hot water. “My wife refuses to use tap water for any drinking purpose,” he added.

While disgusted by the situation in his own home, Grech didn’t realize the scope of the problem until he became president of the Malverne Civic Association. In 2009, while serving in the leadership position, he received numerous complaints from residents living in the village about the state of their drinking water, many whose experiences were worse than his. It prompted him to send a letter on behalf of them all to the President of Long Island American Water Company, Bill Varley.

“Varley was great,” Grech said. “He called me back and said they were building a water treatment plant” to address the problem, which he learned was high levels of naturally-occurring iron in the water.

The $7.5 million iron removal plant, located on Franklin Avenue (It’s the building located near the Malverne DPW and .) opened in late October 2010 with a special ribbon-cutting ceremony and a tour of the facility. ( to see the video.)

“Iron has always been an issue in area…it’s an issue for everyone living on the South Shore, but primarily for those in the western [part],” Varley told Patch in an interview on Monday.  “It’s naturally occurring, it’s not a health hazard, but it is a nuisance.”

Varley explained that iron levels do rise over time and when they reach certain levels, they need to be treated.

 “About four years ago, we took an aggressive approach,” he said, adding that the plant they opened in Malverne is their sixth iron treatment facility and they have plans to open a seventh in the area. It is capable of filtering out some of the iron from 4 million gallons of water.

The only problem is that despite what most residents believe it hasn’t been put into use yet.

“We’re trying to get past this last little hurdle,” Varley said.

As he explained, the tanks that filter out the water have been painted with a protective coating that needs to cure completely before the Nassau County Health Department can give Long Island American Water the green light to begin operating them.

“We’ve been having some difficulty,” Varley said, adding that the company continues to sample the water in the tanks and send it to the health department, but tests keep coming back showing some residual from tank’s coating is still present.

“The plant should’ve been on line a month ago,” Varley said, explaining that the curing process is taking longer than anticipated. “The main objective is that the water is safe and we have to make sure all criteria is met with the health department…we just have to keep sampling it. Be patient, help is on the way.”

Varley admitted that the company should have reached out to residents to inform residents about the setbacks.  “I completely understand where customers are coming from.”

He said he plans to attend the next village board meeting to address residents’ concerns, but as of now, he still does not have a definite start date for the plant to begin functioning. “It could be a week or it could be a couple weeks,” he added.

When the plant does go on line, he says, residents can expect to see a dramatic improvement in their water.

Right now, the brown tinge and residue they are seeing is iron. Long Island American Water treats the water with siliciates to sequester the iron, meaning that it binds it to the H20 so it isn’t visible. (According to Varley, siliciates are commonly used and approved by the Nassau County Department of Health.) However, over 120 degrees this chemical will start to break down, which is why most residents report seeing the putrid color when running hot water. The residue appearing in some peoples’ sinks and tubs is also sediments of iron that collect at the bottom of people’s tanks and when water levels are low it can get into the pipes.

“Once we get the plant up and running you will see a noticeable change,” Varley said.

He also says those residents that have tried to address the problem on their own by purchasing filtration systems, can also expect to see improvements in the lifespan of their filters.

"They’re filtering out some of the same iron we’re going to be filtering out, but we’ll be doing it on a bigger level,” Varley said.

Bill Coogan, a 13-year Malverne resident who lives down the block from the new iron treatment plant, has spent hundreds of dollars on a whole house filtration system for his home. Like so many residents he too was struck by the “gross” water that he was using to bathe his two kids, and he even noticed it was causing his family’s laundry to look dingy.

“I always had brown water coming out of the pipes,” he said, but unlike many of the other residents who joined Grech’s Facebook group, Coogan, who has a degree in mechanical engineering, knew the cause was iron build-up.

About every two months he spends $80 on two filters for his system, which cost about $200 to install. The cartridges are supposed to last up to six months, but the high iron levels in water coming to his home, shorten their life span significantly.

 In fact, he has had to switch to a more porous type of filter that allows more sediment to creep into his water supply because the more stringent ones were clogging after only two weeks and driving up his expenses.

The first time he pulled one of these filters out about nine months ago, it was covered in a brown slime. “It was just disgusting,” said Coogan, who was prompted to take a drive over the Long Island American Water’s headquarters in Lynbrook to show them what his filter had caught.

 Coogan said Varley himself saw him waiting in the office and asked if he could help him.

 “I held up this nasty thing and talked with him for 40 minutes” Coogan said. “He brought in one of his lead engineers…and they were touting this new filtration plant they were building on Franklin Avenue.”

 Coogan also received the tutorial on the water’s naturally occurring iron levels and the chemical process the company uses  to prevent the iron from coming out as particulate.

“By doing that, it allows them to pass the water quality standards for the amount of iron in the water,” Coogan said. “They chemically treat the water to keep the iron in solution so as not to see it.”

 While some residents have been instructed to keep their hot water heaters below 120 degrees to prevent undoing this process, Coogan said this solution is “unacceptable.”

 “That’s not a valid thing to tell people they can’t heat their water over 120 degrees,” he said. “The company has a moral obligation to give us water that’s clean. That water might meet minimal standards for water quality, but that brown stuff coming out looks dirty.”

 Like Coogan, Grech is also not satisfied with these “scientific explanations,” he says. “I’m not going to accept that it’s just the way it is, that it’s in our house, that it’s the home…it’s going to need to be addressed by Long Island Water at the highest level.”

Grech plans to circulate a petition both online and by recruiting volunteers to help him go door-to-door with a paper version, and look into having the water independently test.

 “Bottom line is that it’s water. It’s a basic element. There should not be a scientific explanation for brown, rusty water or sediment in tap water,” he says. “No one wants to know the science behind it. I’m not a scientist – I just want clean water.”

Varley assures residents, “We’re going to keep addressing iron issue, because it’s not going to go away.”

Clioscribe February 01, 2011 at 07:37 PM
Excellent story - thanks. It is a relief to know that the new facility is not running yet, and can still (hopefully) improve the water quality.
Tom Grech February 01, 2011 at 08:42 PM
Tara-Great work on reporting the story....Kind of shocked that the multi-million dollar plant is not even doing what is was supposed to do and NO ONE outside of American Water knew.....go to www.facebook.com and sign up to "I Love Malverne but hate the brown water (from LI Water)" to learn more and stay informed.....
Jennifer Derrig February 01, 2011 at 11:39 PM
I live in lynbrook it's not just the hot water the cold water is tinted too my laundry is all stained and I wash in cold and I see it in my dog's dish it's white plus it stinks like rotten eggs.... It's sickening ... We never had this problem living in Franklin square for ten years....
Gina Genti February 02, 2011 at 01:53 AM
Wasn't there a ribbon cutting ceremony at the water treatment facility last fall? Now I"m reading it's not even online yet. I'm willing to wait to see what the differences are when it's is up and running. Any idea how we will be made aware of this?
Tara Conry (Editor) February 02, 2011 at 05:31 AM
Gina, LI American Water has agreed to notify me as soon as they have a date for when the plant will begin operating...they will also be present at the Village Board meeting tonight so we can get more information.
Dawn Wladyka February 02, 2011 at 12:17 PM
Excellent story Tara! Thanks for taking the time to get someone to talk about this!! Do they plan on continuing to treat the water with the same chemicals/silicates, or will the plant take care of that?
walter February 02, 2011 at 12:23 PM
Good story. Have had issue for years. Thought it was our hot water heater. My daughter refuses to give our grandchildren a bath in our home. Keep up the heat on the water company
Beth February 02, 2011 at 08:57 PM
I live in West Hempstead and we have the same problem with both the hot and cold water. We've replaced our hot water tank and recently drained it in an attempt to get "clean" water, to no avail. Last week we spent two nights in a hotel in another state and had beautiful clear blue water. My kids were amazed; they didn't remember ever seeing water like that. No one wants to bathe in this disgusting brown tinted water and I even use bottled water to cook. Thank you, Tara, for this story. Will you please let us know the date for the plant opening?
Shea Klecko 73 February 03, 2011 at 03:15 AM
Glad to see this article on here. We moved into Malverne 2 years ago & noticed this problem right away. I thought it was my hot water heater at first. Then I thought the water company was flushing hydrants. Finally I asked one of my neighbors if this was a recurring an issue. I'm glad to see the Civic Association is taking up this battle with the water company.
Al Brown February 03, 2011 at 03:14 PM
Will this new water iron treatment facility send water to residents of West Hempstead as well?
Tom Grech February 03, 2011 at 03:22 PM
Unknown...please bring your questions to the meeting we've set up at the Malverne Public Library, Thursday, Feb 10 at 7:30 pm....
Brian Martin February 06, 2011 at 02:10 AM
I'm in West Hempstead also and have been replacing water heaters (new one in December) and R.O. system filters every couple of years due to lime and rust. enough is enough. We have some of the highest rates and should be getting spring water quality, not the brown slime we do get. time for a rate DE-crease for as couple of years.
Paul February 06, 2011 at 06:59 AM
You know something, the brown tap water IS a definite health hazard. Whenever my grandmother took iron pills or ate a lot of vegetables with a high iron content, she experienced anal bleeding. I've also experienced this health condition sporadically, and I always drink the town's tap water straight from the faucet and use it for cooking. My condition started right when the tap water became brown, and it's been reoccurring sporadically to coincide with the periods of brown tap water. I should sue both the Long Island American Water Company and the Town of Malverne for this health hazard!!
Jasmin February 07, 2011 at 03:47 PM
Hi Tara, I work at FOX 5 News. We are doing a story to tonight on this topic for our 10PM news. We would love to interview you on the subject some time today. Would you be available? If you are available please call the assignment desk at 212 452 3808 and we will set something up. Thanks so much!! Jasmin
Luis February 08, 2011 at 04:18 AM
Hi Tara, I just saw the report on Fox 5 News, I thought it was just this block that was affected. I recently move to Waterview avene just two blocks away from the water company pump station on Lakeview ave. Everyone on my block is having the same brown water and smell. So far I have had to remove my hot water tank, and install a whole house water filtration system. But filters only last two month due to the high sediments in the water. I have called the water company customer service center on this problem for over a year now with no follow up or explanation from them. I will come down to the Malverne Public Library, Thursday, Feb 10 at 7:30 pm.
Tara Conry (Editor) February 08, 2011 at 04:30 AM
Thanks for the feedback Luis. I live not far from you, but our water is dingy but not dark brown. I"ll see you- and everyone else at the meeting. Definitely bring photos if you do have them or send me an e-mail if you need me to take photos or even video of what you've been experiencing. I've learned from speaking with residents that people are experiencing different problems - for some it's really brown water, others only see sediment after they drain the tub, some have this happening more frequently, others see it only once a week on the bottom level of their house....while there are the lucky residents who don't report any problems. I think we need to document specific details so the company can address all of the issues - perhaps there's other factors besides the iron at play.
Anna February 09, 2011 at 05:00 AM
I live in Lakeview (next to Malverne) and, just yesterday, we spoke about this at our local council meeting. This is a big problem in our town as well. For years our household has had dingy to brown water coming out of its taps and like some people here in the comment section, thought it might have been a water heater/tank problem. Wish we'd done a whole-house filtration system before, but now we're definitely looking into getting one. I've had it with money wasted on brand-new white towels that become dingy and yellow with just the first wash. Also, how "safe" are those chemicals/silicates that are being used to treat the iron?
Dawn Wladyka February 09, 2011 at 01:54 PM
Just read in Newsday that the Nassau Dept of Health claims our water meets EPA standards. Is that with or without the silicates in the water? Definitely a question for Thursday.
Sharon Sturiano-rocco February 10, 2011 at 04:22 AM
I am currently living in Malverne Park on Atlas Ave and we have had multiple issues with brown water. Since moving here in 2003 I have noticed that my drinking water, tub and toilet water have been brown. My toilet has a brown ring which does not go away. My washer also omits brown, smelly water when the rinse cycle is done. What is this brown water doing to our health?
Jeff w February 11, 2011 at 03:54 AM
I live in west hempstead. We also have brown water. Smelly and terrible tasting even when filtered. We go through filters extremely fast. The filters literally clog to the point that water simply will not flow through the filter. We have called the water company many time and they tell us it is fine. They also think the solution is to add more chemicals that disolve the rust and make the water clear but when heated the rust shows again because the chemicals to not rid the water of the rust, they simply dissolve and disburse the rust. The water is absolutely disgusting. We do not want chemical plants to make our water look better. From what I understand about our water is that it is stored in underground or low grade concrete tanks as opposed to a water tower. In addition the pipes that deliver the water are ancient. I would not be surprised if our main supply lines are soldered with lead. In this day and age we should be able to have clean water. Our taxes are very high, and we pay for water. We can not even brush our teeth in comfort. This is absolutely disgusting and unacceptable. Please do not forget us. I have a home and a business in west Hempstead, My business actually receives water from a different water company. Please help us too.
Tom Grech February 11, 2011 at 04:09 PM
Jeff W-Help us help you...get involved...sitting on the sidelines won't get it done. We know from experience that unless people get involved it will continue to the problem it has been for years....stay involved via facebook, http://www.facebook.com/#!/home.php?sk=group_193845250627907&ap=1 as well as www.malvernecivic.org Tom
Matthew C. March 19, 2012 at 04:49 AM
I live in Franklin Square and this is still a huge problem over a year later.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something