No Memorial Wall for Malverne Firefighter: Gov. Cuomo Vetoes 'Brady Bill'

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo kills bill that would have placed fallen firefighter Paul Brady's name on a state memorial. Malverne Volunteer Fire Department "surprised" and "outraged."

Friends, family and 'brothers' of fallen Malverne firefighter Paul Brady had hoped to celebrate the new year by learning that after years of waiting, rallies and campaigning, Paul's name would finally be placed on a state memorial to honor his legacy.

Brady, 42, died during a while performing his duties as a volunteer firefighter in Malverne on June 30, 2006. He had been working atop a heavy rescue fire truck that day, performing maintenance activities as part of training, when another firefighter, unaware of Brady's presence atop the vehicle, began to drive the truck, causing him to hit a ceiling beam and fall off. Brady suffered serious internal injuries, which led to his death later that day.

The United States Department of Justice and the New York State Workers' Compensation Board determined that Brady died in the line of duty and the latter awarded death benefits to his widow. Brady was honored by the National Fallen Firefighters Foundation and Nassau County, but the New York State Fallen Firefighter Memorial Committee refused to add Brady's name to their monument in Albany, denying multiple requests.

However, things were looking up for Brady's supporters in 2011. Both the New York State egislation to place his name on the wall and on Dec. 21 the bill was sent to NYS Gov. Andrew Cuomo. If the governor signed his name, Brady's would soon appear on the memorial, but instead, just two days into 2012, the bill was killed.

Gov. Cuomo vetoed the legislation on Jan. 2, and wrote in a memo, "I am sympathetic to the families and colleagues of every firefighter who has died in circumstances that do not make that firefighter eligible for inclusion on the State Memorial Wall, and this was a very difficult decision, but there should not be one set of eligibility criteria for volunteer firefighters and another for paid firefighters."

The news of the governor's veto came as a shock to Brady's family and his fellow firefighters, David Gildea, a spokesman for the Malverne Volunteer Fire Department, told Patch.

"We were very surprised and very disappointed," Gildea said. "We had no reason to believe it wouldn’t be signed considering how it passed [the Legislature] with such great support."

Gildea said he read the governor's brief veto memo, which can be viewed above, but felt it lacked an explanation for why he chose not to support the bill.

"Honestly, I don’t know if there could be [an explanation] that would be acceptable to us," he added. "We know the circumstances and the process and we know what's right...Paul deserves that honor and there appears to be no reason for it to be denied. "

Right now, the "outraged" department is exploring its options, Gildea says, adding, "We are not done fighting. We hope this is rectified."

What do you think of the governor's decision?

Robert J. Pape, Jr. January 05, 2012 at 07:14 PM
Firefighter Paul Brady of the Malverne Fire Department was tragically killed in the line of duty. Honor his ultimate sacrafice on the Wall. Thank you.
Robert J. Pape, Jr. January 05, 2012 at 07:28 PM
Brothers and Sisters in the Fire Service: Let's get this bad decision changed through the political process. Let's use our contacts in government and our voting block to get the right thing done. Stop wasting time with this guy Cook and stop criticizing past decisions involving other departments. We are better than that. If we stick together, justice will be done and Paul Brady will get the memorial he deserves.
Robert J. Pape, Jr. January 05, 2012 at 11:41 PM
When a firefighter takes the Oath of Office that is his or her act of bravery and heroism. After that, EVERYTHING ELSE IS IN THE LINE OF DUTY.
Tom Grech January 06, 2012 at 01:17 AM
Not a fireman, paid or unpaid but I have total respect for both. I did some research and was given the following info via facebook: Tom Grech This just in from a friend, attorney and fellow Malvernite who actually researched the bill: Tom Grech Hey - I took a look at the Brady bill stuff. Here's what I think the Governor's decision comes down to. The Memorial has a set of criteria: http://www.dhses.ny.gov/​ofpc/memorial/documents/​FallenFFsfinalcriteria.pdf It applies equally to paid and volunteer firefighters. The bill did not simply direct that Brady's name be added despite the committee's decision that his death did not meet the criteria, it amended the law relating to volunteer firefighters' benefits to change the criteria for volunteer firefighters only. Here's the text. http://open.nysenate.gov/​legislation/bill/S4655-2011 The Patch article quoted Cuomo as saying there should not be different standards for paid/volunteer firefighterss Malverne West Hempstead Herald: According to Assemblyman Harvey Weisenberg, a co-sponsor of the bill, there was a technicality with which Gov. Cuomo took issue. They're working together to fix it and reintroduce the bill. The technicality was related to the use of the word "volunteer" — it will be broadened to include ALL firefighters, paid and volunteer. Story coming out next week, so keep an eye out for it.
Tara Conry January 06, 2012 at 08:53 PM
Just spoke to Assemblyman Harvey Weisenberg about the Brady Bill. Story to come later tonight!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »