West Hempstead Students Lose February Vacation

School board unanimously approves converting five vacation days to instructional days.

There will be no February break for students and teachers of the West Hempstead School District this year.

To make up some of the instructional days that were lost due to Superstorm Sandy and this month's nor'easter, the West Hempstead Board of Education voted unanimously Tuesday night to convert the five scheduled vacation days for February 2013 to school days.

Students will now be expected to report to school on Feb. 18 to Feb. 22, or else they will be credited with "illegal absences."

At the school board's Nov. 20 business meeting, West Hempstead Superintendent John Hogan explained that all schools districts in New York are required to have a minimum of 180 instructional days on their calendars each year. Two of these days can be superintendent's conference days, when only faculty need to report. 

The New York State Education Commissioner could waive five days from the 180-day requirement, and the state legislature could waive an additional five more, as it did last year for some districts upstate that suffered severe flooding from Hurricane Irene.

However, at a meeting Hogan attended Sunday morning with the commissioner, he was told that in order for districts to be eligible for the waivers, should they be granted, they must first demonstrate a good faith effort to restore instructional days from what would be considered discretionary vacation time.

"We're not in winter yet, which is something that the commissioner understands," Hogan said. "He understands that in New York, and on Long Island especially, it's not a far stretch that we may have to take an additional two days depending on the winter we face." (In 2011-12, West Hempstead took no snow days, but in 2010-11, it used three.)

West Hempstead went into the 2012-2013 school year with 182 scheduled instructional days, including two superintendent's conference days, but lost seven in late October and early November as a result of the two major storms, bringing that number down to 175.

To restore the number of instructional days to the required 180, Hogan recommended the board take four out of five days from the February break, keeping schools closed on Presidents' Day, Feb. 18, and the day after Easter, April 1. He explained that certain days, Martin Luther King Jr. Day and Memorial Day for example, are not allowed to be converted to instructional days.

Although President's Day is a federal holiday, districts could schedule classes that day. The days between Christmas and New Year's, as well as the Easter/Passover vacation days could be turned into school days also, but Hogan said he would not advise the board to do this unless it had no other option.

"These days are not only traditional but deemed by many people to be significantly religious," Hogan said. "I told the commissioner, 'You'd have to direct me to take those days before I would take them.'"

Upon a suggestion from Trustee Vincent Trocchia, the board decided to amend Hogan's recommendation to make Presidents' Day (Feb. 18) a school day while leaving the April 1 vacation day intact. Trocchia's reasoning was that this would preserve the full spring break. It would also give the board the option -- should the district have to use a snow day this winter -- to then take April 1 if it needs to in order to maintain 180 instructional days, assuming the waivers are not granted.

Nassau BOCES, which provides services to West Hempstead schools, will decide whether it will be open on these days in February, depending on what the majority of districts in the area decide to do.

"You are not going to get in any new instruction on these days ... If people have vacation plans, they are going," Barbara Keilty-Michaleski, a West Hempstead resident and retired teacher told the board, harking back to her experiences in the schools. 

"Then, that's a crime," Trocchia responded. "Parents need to realize a disaster occurred and certain things have to be met. This is not an ordinary time ... We never, never missed this much time."

If the district has to take more than one snow day this winter and the waivers are not approved, then the board will need to look beyond April 1 and take back additional vacation days in 2013.

What do you think of the board's decision to cancel the February break?

sharon gofberg November 21, 2012 at 03:13 AM
Natalie November 21, 2012 at 04:35 AM
No problem. Great idea, lol now my kids can't drive me nuts that week. Seriously it's a good thing.
Patricia November 21, 2012 at 11:51 AM
Still going on my paid for vacation! Is the district going to reimburse me for the $5000 I paid!
P November 21, 2012 at 01:18 PM
I think the kids should still get Presidents day. Why is it you can take Presidents day but not Martin Luther King day?
S.M. November 21, 2012 at 02:38 PM
Patricia...set a good example for your kids and don't complain. $#!+ happens. It's a life lesson. Why should the district reimburse you? Did it cause the storm?
Savti7 November 21, 2012 at 04:57 PM
NY City teachers lost 3 days of their vacation that week as well. We are not guaranteed vacation President's. Would you rather add on days in June? Or perhaps lose part of Easter week. Put it in perspective! At least you didn't lose your house or your life in the storm. Next time, consider trip insurance.
Patricia November 21, 2012 at 06:12 PM
I do set a good example for my kids! Things do happen but I am not in a position to lose a substantial amount of. Money due to a natural disaster. Family time Abd travel are important too. The trip was planned in the summer and a premium paid for a week when school were supposed to be closed. My child will make up the work and submit all assignments when returned but we are taking that vacation! I understand the district needs to do what it needs to!
Jason November 22, 2012 at 06:37 PM
Your kids should come before any vacation.....
Jason November 22, 2012 at 06:39 PM
Why.........isn't education more important than holidays that are unnecessary and largely ignored.? Another dopey remark!
Jason November 22, 2012 at 06:40 PM
If you truly understand you would not have made the assinine remark,
Jason November 22, 2012 at 06:40 PM
Touche although that's only 1 week they were out 2?
M November 23, 2012 at 11:50 AM
Jason, while your point is valid, you lose credibility by name calling and criticizing, thus making people defensive. BTW, all federal holidays should be treated equally. After all, they are all federal holidays
Savti7 November 23, 2012 at 03:00 PM
Many parents don't always have vacations when their children are on school holidays. So they plan vacations at their convenience and take the children out of school. Personally and professionally, I see nothing wrong with it. Giving your children a chance to experience another country or interesting place is great when you take advantage of local color and culture. Teachers will gladly provide assignments and many have websites that keep kids in touch with school happenings. With technology school is not only in a building and in front of a teacher. My guess is many parents have made similar arrangements and not much learning will go on that week anyway.
Jason November 23, 2012 at 04:46 PM
Point well taken.......my apologies ! When I just think of the taxes I pay for the education results we receive, I too easily become assinine!
Jason November 23, 2012 at 04:48 PM
Gimme a break! Where exactly are they vacationing too,what will they see,where will they go? Sun sand water? family out of town? Hmmm very educational?
P November 24, 2012 at 04:28 PM
Jason, I just want to know why president day can become a school day but not Martin Luther the king day or Memorial Day? And as a federal holiday they shoul still have this day off. There are other vacation days that can be used. I have no problem sendin the kids to school. I just will keep them home for Presidents' Day.
whalepoop November 25, 2012 at 08:18 PM
me, me, me
Matt Matt November 26, 2012 at 05:51 PM
Another example of ineptitude. My child will certainly NOT attend classes that week. Next time, don't turn the high school into a shelter. Further, it was LIPA's responsibility to get the power back on much sooner than it did. Neither of these were my child's fault, and as such, he will not be punished for other's failings. That's a lesson I will not teach him. And opening school on President's day but closing it for Martin Luther King day is despicable. Would the same thing have been done if it were Columbus day? I'm sorry, not on my watch.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something